AFRINIC criticism: what others have said

Do not take our word for it. Researchers at the Internet Governance Project, reporters at The Register and Capacity Media, a member of the RIPE NCC, its managing director and the chief executive of ARIN have each spoken about this dispute. None of them speaks for us, and two of them run registries that wrote to the Government of Mauritius against us. Here is what they said, and when.

What do independent researchers say about AFRINIC’s move against Cloud Innovation?

That it was an overreaction.

In August 2021 the Internet Governance Project, a research group at the Georgia Institute of Technology, examined the attempt by AFRINIC’s management to end our membership. It called AFRINIC’s attack an overreaction to its own past problems, said the principle that addresses may not be used outside the region rests on false premises, and advised AFRINIC to give up the idea that the numbers it allocates cannot be used elsewhere. That is what we have said since 2020: an IP address is a number, and a number has no region.

What do they say about AFRINIC’s receivership?

That it is a remedy, not a collapse.

In October 2023 the Internet Governance Project described the receivership, which the Court ordered on our application, as a structured remediation under court oversight and not a breakdown, and referred to the serious governance problems at AFRINIC that it had set out before. A month earlier Capacity Media had reported the Official Receiver’s own explanation that the order is not a liquidation and that his task was to see a new board in place. And in September 2023 the chief executive of ARIN, another regional registry and no ally of ours, wrote on the NANOG mailing list that the appointment offered a fairly straightforward path to resolution.

What do they say about the registries’ letter to the Government of Mauritius?

That it asked ministers to step into a court case.

In July 2022 the four other regional registries wrote to the Minister of Foreign Affairs and the Attorney General of Mauritius. In that letter they called our litigation vexatious and complained of the courts’ orders. On the members’ list of the RIPE NCC, a member who said plainly that he is no admirer of ours objected that the letter urged the executive branch to intervene in the judicial branch, and added that not all of our lawsuits are without merit. A week after the letter, ruling on the same charge when AFRINIC’s management made it in court, the Supreme Court held that Cloud Innovation “cannot be taxed for resorting to an independent court to safeguard its rights”. Three days after that, the managing director of the RIPE NCC wrote that interfering with the courts had not been the intention.

What do they say about ICANN’s court application?

That ICANN had no standing, and that it overreached.

In June 2025 ICANN applied to the Supreme Court of Mauritius against AFRINIC’s Receiver. The Internet Governance Project reported that the Court held ICANN had no standing to bring the application and declined to dismantle the election’s nominating committee as ICANN had asked. Its researchers called ICANN’s intervention an overreach, and noted that ICANN’s general counsel declared victory in public all the same. Our record shows what the ruling did do: it ordered a communiqué correcting one classification, and it left in place the order of 11 June 2025 directing that we be entered in AFRINIC’s register of members.

What do they say about the annulled election?

That the Receiver gave no explanation for it.

In July 2025 The Register reported that AFRINIC’s Receiver had not explained why he annulled the Board election of June 2025, and that ICANN’s chief executive had criticised him for it and set a deadline that passed without a published answer. We had said at once what happened: the entire election was annulled over “one disputed proxy”, “silencing hundreds of valid votes”.

What do they say about the election of September 2025?

That critics doubt it was run within AFRINIC’s bylaws.

In September 2025 The Register reported critics’ view that the election ran under arrangements that AFRINIC’s bylaws may not allow, and that its sources expected stakeholders to ask the courts of Mauritius whether it was properly run. It reported that seven of the eight directors elected had the endorsement of Smart Africa, a body of 40 member nations, and that some in Africa’s internet community were uneasy at that slate holding a majority. We oppose the application to have those appointments declared valid.

Lu Heng’s Note 54

On Who Gets to Speak for a Continent, a Community, or “The End User”

Who has a mandate to speak for a continent, a community, or “the end user”?

What do they say about a member’s freedom to leave AFRINIC?

That AFRINIC’s new policy blocks the way out in many cases.

In March 2026 The Register reported that AFRINIC’s new transfer policy stops members, in many circumstances, from transferring the addresses AFRINIC assigned out of its region. That is our case: a member must be free to change registry and keep the addresses its network runs on.

Lu Heng’s Note 71

The Policy Mirror

What does a policy manual confess about what an institution thinks it is?

Why does it matter what others say?

Because none of them had a reason to help us.

Researchers who have criticised us called the move against us an overreaction. A member of another registry, no admirer of ours, said its letter asked ministers to step into a court case. Reporters found an election annulled without explanation. Read the court documents and judge for yourself: the ones we rely on are published on this site.