Did Cloud Innovation break AFRINIC’s rules? No.
No. AFRINIC’s management accused us in June 2020 of breaking its rules, and in 2021 it tried to end our membership. The Supreme Court of Mauritius stopped it three times. For the charge that our addresses are used outside its region, the requirement its own letter cited was a bylaw on who may be a member; the one sentence its policy manual has on the subject covers addresses rationed since 2017, and ours were registered between 2013 and 2016. And the member it accuses keeps AFRINIC’s public record more thoroughly than any other: at one point our updates made up about 80% of all updates to its WHOIS database.
Updated
Did Cloud Innovation break AFRINIC’s rules?
No.
We said so to AFRINIC in writing on 13 July 2020: “we strongly deny having acted in any way in breach of the Agreement, Policy Manual and/or the By-laws”. No court has found that we broke any rule of AFRINIC’s. What the Supreme Court of Mauritius has done is restrain AFRINIC, three times in 2021, from ending our membership, and record in 2022 that those then running AFRINIC “deliberately flouted” its order. Six years on, the accusation has been repeated often and proved nowhere.
- Our reply to AFRINIC, 13 July 2020
- Straight answers: did Cloud Innovation break AFRINIC’s rules?
- AFRINIC vs Cloud Innovation
- AFRINIC’s contempt of court
Lu Heng’s Note 65
Running-Code Primacy: The Patch Needed to Preserve the Internet’s Original Design
What single patch would restore the Internet’s original design at the registry layer?
What did AFRINIC’s management accuse Cloud Innovation of?
Three things, in a letter of 23 June 2020, and we answered each on 13 July 2020.
It said our WHOIS records did not match the routing table: it had judged where an address is used by the country in which a network’s number is registered, and “there is no reliable or meaningful correlation” between the two. It said the use did not match the need we had stated, and that we had not told it of changes: we assign addresses “based on a strict need-basis only”, and we had notified it through its own WHOIS database, “promptly, accurately and fully”. And it said most of our addresses were not used inside its region, “as required by section (6) of the AFRINIC Bylaws”: a section that defines who may be a member.
Lu Heng’s Note 63
On When the Bookkeeper Auditions for Olympus
What happens when a bookkeeper begins to believe the ledger is a throne?
Is there a rule that AFRINIC addresses must be used in Africa?
Not for our addresses, and not as a general rule.
AFRINIC’s policy manual has one sentence on use outside its region, section 5.4.6.2, and it stands among the conditions of the “soft landing”, the rationing whose first phase began on 31 March 2017. Our four blocks were allocated between July 2013 and September 2016. AFRINIC’s own letter of 23 June 2020 named the soft-landing policy as the exception; for a general rule it pointed to section 6 of its bylaws, which, as we replied, “does not specify anything in regards to the manner or location of usage”. Lu Heng’s words for a registry that claims a rule its policy does not contain: “It is the difference between applying policy and manufacturing policy.”
- Is there a rule against using AFRINIC addresses outside Africa?
- Does that rule cover Cloud Innovation’s addresses?
Lu Heng’s Note 61
Running-Code Betrayal: How the RIR System Turned Consensus Against the Technical Community
Does “community consensus” give a room the right to rule over networks that are already running?
Does Cloud Innovation keep AFRINIC’s records up to date?
More thoroughly than any other member.
Every assignment we make is entered in AFRINIC’s WHOIS database, the public record of which network uses which addresses: “We take great pains to accurately register each assignment”, as we wrote to AFRINIC on 13 July 2020. At one point our updates alone made up about 80% of all the updates made to that database. AFRINIC’s own letter says its charges came from “an examination of the utilisation records registered in the AFRINIC WHOIS database”. The record of where our addresses are used is in that database because we put it there. A member with something to hide does not fill a registry’s database with its own updates.
Lu Heng’s Note 2
The Internet’s Address Book — and Why “Digital Sovereignty” Is a Dangerous Fantasy
If a registry is only an address book, what does “digital sovereignty” actually control?
What have the courts done about the accusation?
They have stopped AFRINIC from acting on it, and none has upheld it.
In March 2021, on the first day of a national lockdown in Mauritius, “when access to justice was very limited”, AFRINIC’s management gave us 30 days to answer what the Court later called “purported breaches”, or face termination at its “sole discretion”. The Judge in Chambers restrained it on 29 March, 13 July and 3 December 2021; the last order protects our membership until the dispute is finally determined. On 19 July 2022 the Supreme Court held that Cloud Innovation “cannot be taxed for resorting to an independent court to safeguard its rights”. No court has found that we broke a rule. Nor has any court ruled on leasing, and no one ever said one had: a lawful business needs no court approval.
Lu Heng’s Note 50
On When a Registry Can Destroy Without Cost — and Why the System Then Dies With It
What happens when a registry can destroy a network at a cost of one hundred dollars?
Who has broken the rules at AFRINIC?
Those who have run it, and people inside it.
The Supreme Court’s judgment of 19 July 2022 records that those then running AFRINIC “deliberately flouted” its order of 13 July 2021. AFRINIC’s own audit, published in January 2021, counted 2,371,584 addresses misappropriated from its pool, from the inside. In 2025 AFRINIC’s Receiver annulled a whole election over, as we said at the time, “one disputed proxy”, and held the rerun without the proxy voting that Article 12.12 of AFRINIC’s constitution allows. On our information, more than 2,000 resource members have been left off its register of members. The rules broken at AFRINIC were not broken by us.
Lu Heng’s Note 32
On The Agency Problem at the Core of Internet Governance
What happens when those who govern a system neither own it nor bear its risks?