ICANN and AFRINIC: what ICANN did, in court and out

ICANN recognised AFRINIC as a regional internet registry in 2005. It does not own AFRINIC and is not one of its members: AFRINIC had been a company in Mauritius for a year before ICANN recognised it. Since June 2025 ICANN has gone to the Supreme Court of Mauritius, where the Court found it had “no locus standi”, put AFRINIC “on notice that a compliance review may well be necessary”, and joined the case in which we ask for AFRINIC to be wound up. Here is what ICANN did and said, in its own words and the Court’s.

Updated

What is ICANN to AFRINIC?

The body that recognised it as a registry, not one that owns it or runs it.

ICANN recognised AFRINIC on 8 April 2005 and calls itself “the accrediting organization of AFRINIC”. The tie is a policy document called ICP-2, a memorandum with the five registries and a service agreement. ICANN is not a member of AFRINIC and no part of the State of Mauritius. AFRINIC is a private company there: it answers to its members and to the Supreme Court. And of the register a registry keeps, ICANN itself has written: “This register acts like a phone book.”

Lu Heng’s Note 19

Why RIRs Do Not Have Authority — and Why “Community Sovereignty” Breaks the System

What is the difference between authority and cooperation, and which one do registries have?

Did ICANN take AFRINIC to court?

Yes, in June 2025, and the Court found that it had no standing.

ICANN applied to the Supreme Court of Mauritius against AFRINIC’s Receiver (SC/COM/MOT/000442/2025); we were not a party. The minutes of 19 June 2025 record that “the applicant has no locus standi to enter such an application before this Court”, call its insistence that the nominations committee be dismantled “inappropriate of the applicant”, and end: “the application is otherwise set aside”. The next day ICANN announced it under a title that begins “ICANN Obtains Successful Court Ruling”. What the Court did order was a communiqué from the Receiver. Its ruling contains no order cancelling the order of 11 June 2025, which directs that we be entered as a member.

Lu Heng’s Note 62

Mandate Laundering: From RIR Fantasy to Transition Architecture

When does an institution stop performing authority and start believing it possesses it?

Did ICANN threaten to withdraw AFRINIC’s recognition?

It put AFRINIC on notice.

On 25 June 2025 ICANN wrote that it was “formally putting AFRINIC on notice that a compliance review may well be necessary”, and on 3 July 2025 that it “reserves all rights to initiate a compliance review of AFRINIC”. A compliance review tests whether a registry still meets the criteria on which ICANN recognised it. We read that as a warning that AFRINIC’s recognition was at stake, and we did not wait for a collapse: in July 2025 we asked the Court for an orderly winding-up, and ICANN and the Number Resource Organization for a successor registry.

Lu Heng’s Note 17

On the ICP-2 Revision, RIR Failure Standards, and Why Power Must Remain Bottom-Up

Who should decide when a registry has failed: its members, or the institutions above it?

Is ICANN a party to the case to wind AFRINIC up?

Yes, since 14 May 2026.

In July 2025 we petitioned the Court to wind AFRINIC up under its supervision (SC/COM/PET/000508/2025). ICANN applied that month to join, and ten months later the Judge in Chambers gave it leave to intervene, once we, the respondent to its application, were “no longer objecting”. The order decides nothing about the winding-up itself. ICANN’s spokesperson told The Register what it wants the Court to understand: that “numbering resources allocated through AFRINIC are not assets of AFRINIC”. On that much we agree. The numbers are not AFRINIC’s: a registry records them, and the networks that run on them are the ones they serve.

What has ICANN to do with Smart Africa?

It gave money to Smart Africa’s blueprint, and says it asked for no plan for AFRINIC.

ICANN signed a memorandum with Smart Africa in November 2024 and, by its own account, “contributed $40,000” to Smart Africa’s internet governance blueprint. After Smart Africa’s endorsed candidates took seven of AFRINIC’s eight elected seats, ICANN’s chief executive wrote on 18 November 2025 that any change to AFRINIC’s governance “must be discussed and decided by the AFRINIC members and the African Internet community”, and on 24 November that ICANN “did not request Smart Africa to deliver any proposals on the governance of AFRINIC”.

Who decides AFRINIC’s future, according to ICANN?

Its members, by ICANN’s own account.

ICANN’s chief executive wrote on 18 November 2025 that “we believe that AFRINIC members must determine its future”. We agree, and we hold ICANN to it. The members voted in June 2025. AFRINIC’s Receiver annulled that vote over, as we said at the time, “one disputed proxy”, and ICANN wrote on 3 July 2025 that the annulment “seems a logical first step”. Either the members decide, or those above them decide which of their votes count.

What does Cloud Innovation ask of ICANN?

That it keep to its own words.

If a register “acts like a phone book”, the keeper of a phone book does not decide who may have a telephone. If AFRINIC’s members “must determine its future”, then the members elect the Board under the constitution as written, and the Supreme Court of Mauritius settles what is disputed. And if a registry fails, what must survive is the record, not the gatekeeper: that is why we asked for a successor registry, so that every network keeps its numbers and its service.